MCG Legal    Blog    Child Relocation Disputes

Parenting disputes involving the relocation of a child or children of a relationship are relatively common and always controversial. Recent legal developments result in the establishment of the following legal principle:-

“Where a parent of a child or children is seeking an order from the court permitting them to relocate with the children away from the other parent of the children, the best interests of the child or children will be of paramount importance when deciding the matter.”

Essentially, the Court will be asked to make a ruling that the advantages of permitting relocation (in the long term) outweighs the advantages of making orders requiring the parent requesting relocation to remain.  Courts have previously accepted that the happiness and contentment of the children depend largely on the happiness and contentment of their parents.

A successful argument for or against relocation, must be able to demonstrate to the court that their position is in the best interests of the child.  In one case a parent was able to convince a court that they would be miserable if relocation was not permitted.  And further, that their misery would impact negatively on their parenting ability.

The rebuttal argument generally involves the other parent presenting evidence to the court about the impact the relocation will have on their relationship with the children and that they would not be able to effectively participate in major decisions in the children’s lives, but in many post separation families the reality is that continuing inter parental conflict, either at changeovers, or in the children’s presence, exposes the children to harm.  On that basis communication between the parents should be limited and equally participating in major decisions about the children’s lives is not in their best interests.

Parenting disputes generally involve the courts adopting an individualised discretionary approach to their decision making, because each case has its own unique factual circumstances.  Ultimately the court is responsible for determining how much weight is placed on the evidence in favour of one party, or against another.

The generally accepted `order of things’ in applying relocation rules is; a statement from the court that the best interests of the child remain paramount; an examination of the relevant factors described in the Family Law Act 1975; the presumption of equal shared parental responsibility and any rebuttal evidence; and a consideration of equal and substantial and significant time.  Whilst this procedure appears to provide definitive guidelines about how the courts approach relocation cases, discretion is still an acceptable influence in the outcome of many relocation cases.

The overwhelming factor in all relocation cases is that the children’s best interests is of paramount importance.  How that principle is implemented depends on the circumstances of the case.

If you have a child relocation dispute, we invite you to call our family lawyers on (07) 5591 2222 or contact us regarding a free 30-minute initial consultation.

Recent Articles

Child Custody & Parenting Disputes

Many relationship breakdowns involve children – which leaves the question, “How will the children spend time with their mother and father post separation?”.  The paramount consideration in all disputes involving children is the concept of the “child’s best interestsR...

Read More

DNA Testing & Paternity

A relationship breakdown involving children can occasionally raise questions about the paternity of the child.  Ultimately DNA testing will determine beyond any reasonable doubt who the child’s parents are, but other matters are taken into account before that DNA test is conducted. A child bor...

Read More

Grandparents Rights to See Grandchildren

A relationship breakdown involving children not only affects the parents directly involved, but often the extended family members such as grandparents. The Family Law Act 1975 (“the legislation”) supports the generally held view that children should be entitled to have a relationship with their g...

Read More

Child Support Agreements

A written agreement between parents or carers of children about the payments to be made in support their children is called a child support agreement.  Child support can be made in all sorts of ways, e.g. direct payment of a set amount to one of the parents/carers into their nominated bank account e...

Read More

Child Location and Recovery Applications

Some post separation parenting disputes involve the removal of children from their geographical location. Changing a child’s living arrangements, such that it makes it significantly more difficult for the child to spend time with a parent is a major change in a child’s life and something ...

Read More

Pre Relationship Binding Financial Agreements

It is possible for two parties about to enter into a relationship to enter into a legally binding financial agreement which details how “pre-relationship assets” and “matrimonial assets” will be divided in the event of separation. It is important that both parties entering int...

Read More

Consent Orders & Separation Agreements

Your relationship has broken down and like many couples you have accumulated assets during that relationship.  You can agree on how your property should be divided without any court intervention and the most effective way to distribute the matrimonial assets is through one of the following legal ag...

Read More

Child Relocation Disputes

Parenting disputes involving the relocation of a child or children of a relationship are relatively common and always controversial. Recent legal developments result in the establishment of the following legal principle:- “Where a parent of a child or children is seeking an order from the court per...

Read More

Family Mediation Services

Mediation is a process in which parties to a dispute, with the assistance of a neutral third party (the mediator), identify the disputed issues, develop options, consider alternatives and endeavour to reach an agreement. The mediator has no authority to bind participants to a negotiated agreement, bu...

Read More

Spousal Maintenance

One party to a marriage (read into this de facto) is liable to maintain the other party to the marriage if the other party is unable to support themself adequately and to the extent the first party is reasonably able to do so. Before making any spousal maintenance orders a court must consider what pr...

Read More

Property Settlements - for both married and de facto relationships

Sadly, not all relationships last. Many couples are able to successfully negotiate the division of their assets and care of their children without legal intervention. But, there are some who cannot and that’s where we get involved. This article will explain the general court processes and the...

Read More

Resolving Financial Matters in Family Law

In resolving property matters arising from the breakdown of either a marriage or a de-facto relationship, the Family Law Court and the Federal Circuit Court of Australia have jurisdiction to resolve these matters pursuant to the Family Law Act 1975. With regard to de-facto relationships, there are a...

Read More