MCG Legal    Blog    Child Relocation Disputes

Parenting disputes involving the relocation of a child or children of a relationship are relatively common and always controversial. Recent legal developments result in the establishment of the following legal principle:-

“Where a parent of a child or children is seeking an order from the court permitting them to relocate with the children away from the other parent of the children, the best interests of the child or children will be of paramount importance when deciding the matter.”

Essentially, the Court will be asked to make a ruling that the advantages of permitting relocation (in the long term) outweighs the advantages of making orders requiring the parent requesting relocation to remain.  Courts have previously accepted that the happiness and contentment of the children depend largely on the happiness and contentment of their parents.

A successful argument for or against relocation, must be able to demonstrate to the court that their position is in the best interests of the child.  In one case a parent was able to convince a court that they would be miserable if relocation was not permitted.  And further, that their misery would impact negatively on their parenting ability.

The rebuttal argument generally involves the other parent presenting evidence to the court about the impact the relocation will have on their relationship with the children and that they would not be able to effectively participate in major decisions in the children’s lives, but in many post separation families the reality is that continuing inter parental conflict, either at changeovers, or in the children’s presence, exposes the children to harm.  On that basis communication between the parents should be limited and equally participating in major decisions about the children’s lives is not in their best interests.

Parenting disputes generally involve the courts adopting an individualised discretionary approach to their decision making, because each case has its own unique factual circumstances.  Ultimately the court is responsible for determining how much weight is placed on the evidence in favour of one party, or against another.

The generally accepted `order of things’ in applying relocation rules is; a statement from the court that the best interests of the child remain paramount; an examination of the relevant factors described in the Family Law Act 1975; the presumption of equal shared parental responsibility and any rebuttal evidence; and a consideration of equal and substantial and significant time.  Whilst this procedure appears to provide definitive guidelines about how the courts approach relocation cases, discretion is still an acceptable influence in the outcome of many relocation cases.

The overwhelming factor in all relocation cases is that the children’s best interests is of paramount importance.  How that principle is implemented depends on the circumstances of the case.

If you have a child relocation dispute, we invite you to call our family lawyers on (07) 5591 2222 or contact us regarding a free 30-minute initial consultation.

Recent Articles

Our Top Australia Day Activities

You can’t beat Australia day on the Gold Coast! Cold drinks, great surf and raucous backyard parties. It doesn’t matter where you turn, you’re in for a good time. If you need some fresh ideas on how to spend your Australia day, check out some of our favourite ways to celebrate Aus...

Read More

Nick's Story

Last month we gave you an insight into MCG Legal’s Principal and founder Matt Gill. This month we’re throwing the spotlight on Nick Harrison! Nick arrived at MCG Legal with a unique blend of theoretical and ‘real life’ experience. Before becoming a lawyer, Nick served the community for appr...

Read More

Everything you need to know about DNA & Paternity testing

In Australia, it is estimated that more than 10,000 people each year sign up to find out whether their child is, in fact, biologically theirs. While that number seems large, it isn’t compared to places like the United States, where there are about five times as many paternity tests per head as...

Read More

Updates On E-conveyancing in NSW

Times are changing, and technology is playing a more pivotal role in conveyancing and the property services industry as a whole. As a Gold Coast law firm that helps clients with conveyancing and property work, we wanted to highlight to all our clients in NSW the changes that have recently been made ...

Read More

Why You Need a Strong Advocate on Your Side

Having a strong advocate on your side is critical. In this piece we dive into why it is so important to get you the best possible outcome. You don’t want a piecemeal lawyer who can’t tell you directly what they believe your best course of action. Having clear advice helps put on the path...

Read More

5 Reasons To Keep Your Will Up To Date

A Will is one of the most important legal documents you will ever sign. Despite this, only 59% of Australians actually have a Will and many of those do not have a Will that reflects their current circumstances. You cannot overlook the importance of planning for your family’s future. If you do ...

Read More

How We Help Clients Referred To Us

For most professional service providers, a great deal of work comes through referrals. The reason for this is that most professionals focus their advice in a particular area, and as such, when questions come up that they cannot help with, they want to make sure their client gets the best advice from...

Read More

Matt's Story

Many of you will know that MCG Legal has been advising Gold Coast businesses for over a decade, but have you heard how we started out? Our Principal and founder Matt Gill started MCG Legal in 2009, but you may not know that before starting his life in law, Matt served for over a decade as a police o...

Read More

What Are My Rights If My Partner Leaves With My Kids?

Children can sometimes find themselves in the middle of separation disputes when one parent tries to relocate the children, such that the relocation makes it significantly more difficult for the child to spend time with the other parent. Obviously, these situations are can be traumatic for everyone,...

Read More

5 Standout Gold Coast Restaurants We Love To Support

We love supporting local businesses. Both with our practice and with our wallets! Especially local restaurants!! It has been a tough market for a lot of restaurant owners in Australia for some years. Rising costs, changing spending habits and shifting demographics have made it hard for even the bett...

Read More

Understanding the Three Types of Child Support Agreements

One of the most stressful parts of a divorce process is dealing with child support. It’s important for anyone who finds themselves in that situation, to understand the different types of agreements you can enter into with your partner. A child support agreement is a written agreement between pa...

Read More

The MCG Legal Story

When you’re busy growing a firm, raising a family, and trying to have a life at the same time, you can neglect to tell your own story (or even reflect on it). This has certainly been the case for us in the past few years. Moving forward though, we’re taking a new direction with our blog ...

Read More